I am mixed, so my skin is kind of in between. It’s slightly darker than tan, but not quite. This is a small cropped photo of what my skin color normally looks like: http://i9.tinypic.com/4i27jbm.jpg

I’m thinking that the #3 shade is my only choice, but I’m worried if it’s just too dark? At times, my facial complexion can be pretty fair, and lighting conditions are a pain to adjust to (I don’t know if fairer-skinned people have this same problem or not)… #2 seems too light, and there isn’t a darker one to choose from. I’m worried that #3 is too dark as it is.

Thanks in advance to anyone who might be able to point me in the right direction–all I’m hearing is good stuff about this product.